
Abstract: The Zilsel Thesis seeks the societal roots of modern science. This study, however, argues that his project was hindered by a logical paradox, preventing his study from truly addressing the question it targets. So far, no study has identified, let alone resolved, this impasse—much less proposed an alternative answer for science’s societal origins. This paper thus exposes the logical dilemma that constrains Zilsel, Needham, and others, and offers a systematic answer to what societal conditions engender science.
Key Words: Zilsel Thesis; Global history of science; Social roots of science
